Boots fit when there is about 1 to 1.5 cm between your longest toe and the end of the boot as you stand, your heel lifts only slightly as you walk, and the widest part of your foot sits at the widest part of the boot without pinching. Tall boots should leave room to slide a finger or two down beside your calf. For a second-hand pair, compare its insole length in cm with boots that already fit you.
The fit checklist
Try boots on late in the day, when feet have swollen a little, in the socks you will wear with them. Fit the longer foot, since one is often slightly bigger.
- Toe room: standing, there is about 1 to 1.5 cm in front of your longest toe.
- Stairs: walking down a few, your toes do not hit the front.
- Heel: it lifts a little in a stiff new pair and hardly at all in a worn one.
- Width: no pressure on your little toe or the joint behind your big toe, and your foot does not bulge over the sole.
- Instep: laces or zips close without pressing on the top of your foot.
- Shaft: a finger or two of room beside your calf, and the top sits below the bend of your knee.
How much room should there be at the toe?
Stand with your weight on both feet and press down at the front of the boot. The Royal College of Podiatry suggests a gap of around 1 to 1.5 cm between the end of your longest toe, which is not always the big toe, and the end of the shoe.
Advertisement
Toe shape changes the numbers. On a round toe, the inside of the boot follows your foot. On a pointed or almond toe, the point is extra length your toes never reach, so the boot needs a longer insole for the same comfort. As a rough guide, a comfortable round-toed boot has an insole about 1 to 1.5 cm longer than your foot, more for thick socks or a pointed toe.
Should boots slip at the heel?
A little, at first. Stiff new leather often lets the heel lift by well under a centimetre until the sole softens and bends with your foot.
Second-hand boots have already been worn in, so a worn pair that slips noticeably at the heel is probably too big. On pull-on styles such as Chelsea boots, slack elastic sides and a heel that lifts out mean the boot is too big or the elastic has lost its spring.
How wide should boots be?
The ball of your foot, its widest part, should sit at the widest part of the boot. If you have wide feet, look for wide or extra wide fittings, which the label or box usually names.
How should tall boots fit around the calf?
You should be able to slide one or two fingers down between the boot and the widest part of your calf. If you plan to tuck jeans in, you need more room than that.
- Measure your calf at its widest point, in the tights or trousers you will wear with the boots.
- Ask the seller for the shaft's circumference at its widest, or its width laid flat, which you double.
- Look for a centimetre or two more than your calf.
Ask for the shaft height too, and compare it with your leg, so the top of a knee-high boot does not dig in when you sit. On ankle boots, the top edge should not sit on your ankle bone, where a stiff collar rubs.
What can a cobbler change?
- Usually possible: stretching a leather boot a little in width; stretching a soft leather calf a little; taking in a leather shaft at its seam; fitting heel grips or tongue pads to stop slipping.
- Possible, with a catch: an extra insole fills a boot that is slightly big, but it also takes away room at the toe.
- Not possible: making a boot longer. Synthetic uppers barely stretch at all.
A leather pair that is right in length but snug across the width can be worth buying; a pair that is too short never is.
How do you check second-hand boots in cm?
The insole length, from the heel to the toe inside the boot, is the one measurement a Rewear listing for shoes and boots asks for, and it is the most useful figure you can get.
- Measure the insole of boots that fit you. Lift the insole out, or slide a strip of card inside and mark where it reaches the toe.
- Compare it with the listing. Within a few millimetres of yours is a good sign. Each whole UK size is only about 8.5 mm longer than the last, so a centimetre is more than a size.
- Save your foot length in your profile, heel to the tip of your longest toe, and a listing with an insole length tells you how it compares. Will it fit? does the same for a pair seen elsewhere.
- Check odd figures. Rewear's Terms treat a measurement within 2 cm of the listing as accurate, and on a boot 2 cm is more than two sizes, so ask how the seller measured if a figure looks wrong for the size.
- Ask for the calf and shaft height on tall boots, since listings do not include them.
Look at the insole and sole photos too. Deep toe impressions, and heels worn down on one side, mean the boots have shaped themselves to someone else's feet. Our guide to buying second-hand winter boots covers those checks, and our UK shoe size conversion guide explains EU and US labels. Heels have rules of their own, in buying second-hand party shoes, and for children, see kids' shoe sizes by age.
Advertisement
Find your next piece
Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.