REWEAR

Buying

Buying second-hand party shoes and heels: what to check

How to check second-hand party shoes and heels from the photos: soles, heel tips, insoles and heel covers, sizing in cm, comfort, and what can be fixed.

When you buy second-hand party shoes or heels, check four things in the photos: the soles under the ball of the foot, the heel tips, the insoles and the covering on the heels. Ask for the insole length in cm rather than relying on the size, especially if you are between sizes, and ask the seller how they were to wear for a whole evening. Worn heel tips are a quick fix for a cobbler; a wobbly heel or a sole worn through is not.

What does the sole tell you?

Look at the photo of the soles before anything else.

  • Light scuffing under the ball is normal after a few wears, even on a nearly new pair.
  • Thinning or a hole under the ball means a leather sole needs replacing, which is a bigger job.
  • A rubber sole guard fitted over a leather sole is a good sign: someone looked after them.
  • A clean sole with the size still printed on it usually means they have barely been worn.

Two of Rewear's flaw tags are made for shoes, "Worn soles" and "Scuffs". Sellers can show each close up, and where Rewear's photo check spotted one, tapping the tag jumps to its photo.

How do you check the heel tips?

The heel tip is the small replaceable pad on the bottom of the heel. When it wears down, the hard core underneath shows through, clicks on hard floors and slips.

  • Worn tips are routine to replace, so they need not put you off, as long as the price allows for it.
  • Tips worn at an angle show how the last owner walked, and the heel above them may be scuffed on that side too.
  • A heel that wobbles or leans is harder to fix. If the listing does not say, ask.
  • Scrapes on the heel covering, the leather or satin wrapped round a stiletto, come from stairs and drain grates. They are hard to repair invisibly.

What do insole marks show?

The insole is where wear shows most honestly. Toe prints, a darkened heel area and a logo rubbed away all mean the shoes have been worn more than a few times. Flattened padding under the ball makes a heel less comfortable than it was new. Look for insole edges peeling up at the heel, too.

What about the uppers?

  • Satin marks easily and water stains are hard to remove, so look closely at the toes.
  • Suede flattens at the toe and the back of the heel.
  • Patent leather can crease or crack across the toe and picks up colour from other shoes.
  • Glitter sheds, leaving bald patches at the toe and where the shoes rubbed together.
  • Straps with extra holes punched in them were altered to fit the last owner. Check elastic in slingbacks for stretching, and ask whether any stones or trims are missing.

What if you are between sizes?

A whole UK shoe size is only a third of an inch, about 8.5 mm, of length, and a half size about 4 mm, so a size label is a blunt tool for heels, where a few millimetres decide whether your foot slides forward.

  • Ask for the insole length in cm, measured inside the shoe from heel to toe. Shoes have only that one measurement on a Rewear listing.
  • Measure a pair that fits you the same way and compare. Our guide to UK shoe sizes and insoles shows how.
  • Slightly big is easier to fix than slightly small. Heel grips or a half insole take up a little room. Leather stretches only a little, and patent and synthetics hardly at all.

Ask the seller to measure carefully: Rewear counts a hand measurement within 2 cm of the listing as accurate, and with shoes even 1 cm matters.

How can you tell if they will be comfortable?

  • Heel height in cm, measured at the back from the floor to where the heel meets the shoe. If there is a platform, the real height you feel is the heel minus the platform.
  • The width of the heel. A block heel spreads your weight; a stiletto puts it on a point.
  • Straps. An ankle strap or T-bar stops your foot sliding forward.
  • The toe shape. A pointed toe needs a longer shoe than a round one for the same foot.

Then ask the person who wore them: "Could you wear them all evening? Did they rub anywhere? Do they come up true to size?"

On Rewear, Women's Shoes has a Heels style, so you can choose it in the search filters, and our guide to Christmas party outfits has ideas for what to wear them with.

Which photos should you ask for?

  1. Both soles, flat on to the camera.
  2. A close-up of each heel tip.
  3. The insoles from above.
  4. The side, to show the heel height.
  5. The inside back of the heel, where the lining wears through.
  6. The size stamp, inside or on the sole.

When they arrive

Try them on indoors on a carpet or a clean floor, so the soles stay as they arrived, and walk about for a few minutes. Check them against the listing first: confirming delivery in the app is what pays the seller. If there is wear the listing did not declare, you have 14 days from delivery to report it.

Before the party, have worn tips replaced, and if new leather soles feel slippery, a few minutes on rough paving or a stick-on sole grip helps. Afterwards, our guide to storing shoes and boots keeps them in shape for next time.

The short version

Check the soles, heel tips, insoles and heel covers in the photos, ask for the insole length in cm and the heel height, and ask how they wore for a whole evening. Worn tips are a quick fix; wobbly heels and soles worn through are not.

Find your next piece

Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.

See what’s for saleSell on Rewear

More from the Rewear blog