The January sales are worth it when you want something new in a particular size, from a shop you already know fits you, at a real discount. Second-hand is usually the better deal when you want a well-made piece, such as a wool coat, leather boots or a good jumper, for a fraction of its original price, or something the shops no longer sell. The simplest way to decide is to compare the total cost for the same quality, know what happens if it does not fit, and check the fit before you pay, whichever you choose.
Start with what you actually need
The most expensive sale purchase is the one you never wear. Before you look at a single price, write a short list of the gaps in your wardrobe. Our guide to building a capsule wardrobe second-hand has a method for working out what those gaps are.
Then, for each item, note:
Advertisement
- what it is, in plain words: a navy wool coat, black ankle boots
- your measurements, or a piece you own that fits
- the most you are willing to pay
With that list, both a sale and a second-hand search become quicker, and much harder to get carried away in.
When the January sales win
- You know the brand fits you. If you always wear the same jeans in the same size, buying them new in a sale is simple.
- You want something hard to find used, such as a specific technical item in a particular size, or basics like underwear and socks.
- The discount is on something you would buy anyway, at a price lower than you have seen it before.
Sale prices are only a good deal compared with what you would otherwise have paid. A coat reduced from a high price can still cost more than an equally good one second-hand.
When second-hand wins
- Quality for the money. Wool, cashmere, leather and good denim keep their quality for years, so a used piece can cost much less than the new equivalent. Our guide to telling a good wool coat shows what to look for.
- Pieces you cannot buy new any more: last season's styles, discontinued lines and vintage.
- Winter wear in January. Many people clear out after Christmas, so winter coats, knits and boots come up while you still need them.
- Things you will wear only a few times, such as a party outfit or a ski jacket for one trip.
Compare the true cost
To compare a sale price with a second-hand one, add everything up.
On Rewear, the total is the item price, plus buyer protection (30p + 3%), plus postage for the delivery service you choose. The price on a listing already includes buyer protection, and postage is shown when you pick a delivery option, before you pay. If you buy two or more pieces from the same seller in one order, you pay postage once, and any bundle discount the seller offers comes off automatically.
For a sale, add delivery, and the cost of sending it back if the shop charges for returns.
Returns are different
Buying new online from a shop, sale or not, you normally have 14 days from delivery to cancel, then another 14 days to send it back. In a shop, a change-of-mind return depends on the shop's own policy, which is often shorter for sale items. Faulty goods are covered either way.
Good to know
Most sellers on Rewear are private individuals, and the 14-day cooling-off period for online shopping does not apply to a private sale. If a piece is not as described, buyer protection still covers you. That is why checking the fit before you buy matters.
Check condition the way you would check a sale label
A sale tells you a piece is new. Second-hand, the condition grade does that job. On Rewear sellers choose one of five: new with tags, new without tags, very good, good and satisfactory. Our guide to condition grades explains what each means in practice.
Read the flaw list too. Sellers can tag flaws such as a small mark, pilling or a zip that needs attention, and show each one close up; a flaw Rewear's photo check found shows its photo number.
Fit first, either way
A low price is no saving on something that does not fit. Before you buy anything, new or used:
- Measure yourself, or measure a piece you own that fits.
- Compare with the listing. On Rewear, coats and jackets have the chest pit to pit, length, sleeve and shoulder; jeans and trousers the waist and hip, laid flat and doubled, plus the inside leg and rise.
- Ask when numbers are missing. A short message to the seller is all it takes.
Save searches rather than scrolling
If you are looking for something specific, save the search on Rewear: the app shows how many new matches have been listed since you last looked. You can also turn on New in your size under Settings, Notifications: at most one notification a day, when three or more new pieces in the sizes on your profile are listed. It is a calmer way to shop than refreshing a sale page at midnight.
Sell before you buy
January is also a good time to clear out. Anything you have not worn since the autumn is worth listing while people are still buying warm clothes. Our guide to decluttering your wardrobe in a weekend is a good place to start.
The short version
Make a list first. Buy new in the sales when you know the fit and want something specific. Buy second-hand for well-made pieces, winter wear and things you cannot find new. Compare the total cost including postage and returns, check condition and fit, and save searches rather than buying on impulse.
Advertisement
Find your next piece
Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.