To check a second-hand jumper before you buy, look where knitwear wears first: the underarms, sides and cuffs for bobbling, the whole knit held up to the light for moth holes and thin patches, the cuffs, hem and neck for ribbing that has lost its spring, and the surface for felting or fading. Light bobbling and a split seam are easy to put right. Felting, widespread thinning and slack cotton ribbing are not, and the price should say so.
This guide is about condition. For fit, see how a jumper should fit, and for judging the yarn itself, our guide to good-quality cashmere.
How bad is the pilling?
Some bobbling is normal on almost any knit. What matters is where it is and what is underneath.
Advertisement
- Light pilling under the arms and along the sides, where your arms rub, comes off in minutes with a fabric shaver or a wool comb.
- Heavy pilling across the front of a piece that is not old suggests a soft, loosely spun yarn that will keep doing it.
- A suspiciously smooth jumper may have been de-bobbled before its photos. That is fine, unless the knit has gone thin from it: thin patches show up as lighter areas against a window.
- Synthetic blends such as acrylic form bobbles that cling, because the strong fibres anchor them. They come off, but they come back.
Are there moth holes?
Moth holes are small, often a few millimetres across, and tend to come in clusters: on the front, the back of the neck, the cuffs and along the folds where a jumper was stored. Clothes moth larvae eat wool, cashmere and other animal fibres, and prefer them unwashed.
Look for grazing too: patches nibbled without going right through, so the knit looks thinner and slightly flat. Grazed areas often become holes. One small, declared hole on a good jumper can be darned and is no reason to walk away; several, or holes with grazing round them, suggest a long-running infestation. Our guide to spotting moth damage covers the other signs, and what to do if a piece arrives with moths.
Have the cuffs and hem lost their spring?
Ribbing should pull in and spring back when stretched.
- Flared cuffs that hang as wide as the sleeve above them have lost their grip and slide down your hands.
- A wavy hem that no longer sits flat has been stretched, often by a jumper being pulled down over the hips.
- A gaping crew neck, or a roll neck that flops, comes from being pulled over heads.
Wool ribbing can sometimes be improved a little by steaming it and drying it flat with the ribs eased together. Cotton and acrylic ribbing rarely recover.
Has it felted or shrunk?
A jumper washed too warm, or agitated too hard, felts: the surface turns dense and slightly fuzzy, the stitches are hard to make out, and the fabric feels stiff. The body and sleeves usually come up shorter than the size suggests.
So compare the measurements with the size on the label. A jumper listing on Rewear has the chest pit to pit, which is half the chest, plus the length, sleeve and shoulder, so a "large" with a short length and sleeve is worth asking about. Felting cannot be undone, but a jumper that has only shrunk a little can sometimes be eased back, as our guide to rescuing a shrunken wool jumper explains.
What else should you look for?
- Snags: a loop pulled out of the surface can be eased back through from the inside with a blunt needle. A snag where the yarn has broken is a hole in the making.
- Shoulder bumps: two points at the shoulders mean it lived on a hanger. They usually steam out, but long hanging can also stretch the length.
- Elbows: thinning or bagging on fitted sleeves.
- Fading: the shoulders and any side that faced a window fade first. Compare with the colour inside a seam.
- Underarms: yellowing on pale knits, and a matted patch from friction.
- Seams: a split along a seam is a quick repair. A tear in the knit beside a seam is not.
- Cardigans: stretched buttonholes and missing buttons.
- Smell: wool holds on to smoke and musty storage smells.
Which photos should you ask for?
- The jumper held up to a window, front and back, to show holes and thin patches.
- The cuffs and hem laid flat, with the ribbing relaxed.
- Close-ups of the underarms and the neck.
- The surface in daylight, close enough to see the stitches.
- The composition and care labels.
On Rewear, sellers can tag flaws such as "Pilling or bobbling", "Small hole", "Stretched or misshapen", "Fading", "Has been repaired" and "Smells of smoke or damp". Where Rewear's photo check spotted a flaw, the listing says which photo. Read the tags, find the close-ups, and message the seller about anything the photos do not cover.
What should condition mean for the price?
Rewear's condition grades help here. Very good means worn a few times with no flaws, so a jumper with visible pilling should not be listed that way. Good means worn, with minor signs of wear, such as light bobbling. Satisfactory means visible wear but still wearable.
As a rough guide to what you can fix yourself:
- Easy at home: light pilling, shoulder bumps, a small snag, a split seam, a missing button, a stale smell.
- Fixable with patience: one or two small holes, which can be darned.
- Not really fixable: felting, widespread thinning or grazing, slack cotton ribbing and fading.
Pay for what the jumper is now, not what it could be.
The short version
Check the underarms, sides and cuffs for pilling, the light for holes and grazing, the ribbing for spring and the measurements for felting. Ask for photos of each, read the flaw tags, and price in anything you cannot fix.
Advertisement
Find your next piece
Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.