A men's shirt fits when the shoulder seams sit on the edge of your shoulder bones, the collar buttons with room for a finger, the front closes without pulling between the buttons, the cuffs reach the base of your thumb, and the hem stays tucked in when you raise your arms. Slim, regular and classic cuts differ mainly in how much room they leave in the chest and waist. To check a second-hand shirt, compare its chest, shoulder, sleeve and length with a shirt you already like.
The fit checklist
Button it up, collar included, then check:
- Shoulders: the seam lands on the outer edge of your shoulder, not down your arm or in towards your neck.
- Collar: one finger slides in at the side of your neck without the collar pressing.
- Chest: no creases pulling out from the buttons, and no gaps opening between them when you sit.
- Waist: tucked in, the fabric does not balloon over your belt. A little blousing is normal on a regular or classic cut.
- Sleeves: with your arms by your sides, the cuff covers your wrist bone. Reach forward and it should not ride far up your forearm.
- Length: raise both arms. A tucked shirt stays tucked.
Shoulders come first
Shoulders are the hardest part of a shirt to change, so check them before anything else. A seam hanging down your upper arm means the shirt is too big through the shoulders, and it will look slouchy under a jacket. A seam sitting in towards your neck means it is too small, and you will feel it pull across your back when you reach forward.
Advertisement
Compare the listing's shoulder figure, seam to seam across the back, with your benchmark shirt. A centimetre either way is rarely noticeable; three or more usually is.
Collar size and your neck
Formal shirts are often sold by collar size in inches, such as 15½ or 16. To find yours, put the tape round the base of your neck, where a collar sits, with one finger between the tape and your skin. A 39 cm reading is about a 15½. A collar that is too tight is hard to fix, since moving the top button gains only a little, so check the collar size whenever a listing gives one.
Sleeve length, and why the label figure differs
The cuff should reach the base of your thumb, just covering the wrist bone. Under a jacket, a little cuff showing at the sleeve end looks neat.
Formal shirts often carry a second number, such as 16/34: a 16 inch collar with a 34 inch sleeve. Shirtmakers usually measure that sleeve from the centre of the back, just below the collar, over the shoulder and down to the cuff. A Rewear listing measures the sleeve from the shoulder seam to the cuff, which is a much shorter figure. To compare the two, add half the shoulder measurement to the listing's sleeve; that comes out close to the label's centre-back figure. A 34 inch sleeve is about 86 cm.
Chest: slim, regular or classic
Double the pit to pit to get the chest all the way round. The shirt needs to measure more than your chest, and how much more depends on the cut: a slim shirt sits close, a regular one gives more room, and a classic cut more again. Two shirts with the same collar size can differ by several centimetres across the chest, which is why the numbers matter more than the label.
If a seller has photographed the shirt being worn, look at the button line. Horizontal creases pulling out from the buttons mean it is too tight.
Length and tucking
If you tuck your shirts in, the hem needs enough length to stay put when you sit down or raise your arms. Worn untucked, the hem should end around the middle of your trouser fly, covering your belt but not reaching your thighs. Shirts cut to be worn untucked often have a straighter, shorter hem; formal shirts usually have a longer curved tail.
What to check in the photos
- Collar and cuffs: fraying along the fold, and a grubby line inside the collar band.
- Underarms: yellowing or stiffness from deodorant. Our guide to removing deodorant marks covers what will come out.
- Buttons: all present, including the spare often sewn inside the hem. A missing one is a five-minute job with our guide to sewing on a button.
What a tailor can and cannot change
- Easy: taking in the side seams, or adding darts at the back, for a slimmer shape; shortening the hem.
- Possible: shortening sleeves, though it means taking off and resetting the cuff, which is fiddlier around the cuff opening.
- Not worth it: shoulders that are too wide or narrow, a chest that is too tight, or a collar that will not close.
So a shirt that is right through the shoulders and collar but a little long or roomy can still be a good buy.
Buying a shirt on Rewear
Men's shirts are listed under Shirts, where the seller can add four figures taken flat: chest pit to pit, length from the highest point of the shoulder, sleeve and shoulder. Lay your favourite shirt face down, buttoned, and take the same four. Save your chest in your profile (the box is labelled Bust) and a listing measured for fit compares its chest with yours. Our guide to measuring clothes for buying online shows the method, and Will it fit? checks a shirt you have found elsewhere.
Missing figures? Message the seller and ask for those four, laid flat. Sellers can tag a missing button, a small mark or fading; look for a close-up of each flaw. Your payment is held until you confirm the shirt arrived as described, and a measurement within 2 cm of the listing counts as accurate under Rewear's Terms, so leave yourself that margin.
Advertisement
Find your next piece
Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.