A good second-hand trench coat fits through the shoulders with room for a jumper underneath, ends at a length that suits your height, and still has its belt, buckles and buttons. The fabric should be a dense, tightly woven cotton or cotton blend that holds its shape, with no fraying at the collar, cuffs or hem. Get those right and a used trench can give you many more years of wear.
How a trench coat should fit
A trench is worn over other clothes, so it needs more room than a blazer. Fit the shoulders first, because a tailor cannot easily change them.
- Shoulders: the seam should sit at the edge of your shoulder, or just past it if you wear thick knits underneath.
- Chest: you should be able to button it over a jumper without the front pulling.
- Sleeves: the cuff should reach the base of your thumb with your arms relaxed. A cuff strap can tighten a sleeve but not lengthen it.
- Length: above the knee is easiest to move in and suits shorter frames; at or below the knee gives more cover in the rain.
Tied, the belt should gather the coat neatly at your waist rather than bunching. Plenty of people knot it at the back instead.
Advertisement
The measurements to ask for
On Rewear, sellers listing a coat are asked for four measurements: chest pit to pit, length, sleeve and shoulder. If they are missing, ask. Lay a coat you own flat, take the same four, double the pit-to-pit figures to compare the chest all the way round, and compare the rest directly. Our guide to measuring clothes for buying online shows how each is taken.
Tip
Many classic trench coats have raglan sleeves, with a seam running diagonally from the collar to the underarm and no shoulder seam. On those, ask for the sleeve from the centre back of the collar to the cuff, and measure your own coat the same way.
Vintage trench coats were often cut fuller in the body and longer in the sleeve than modern ones, so the size label is even less reliable. Go by the numbers, and see our guide to how a winter coat should fit for how much room to leave.
Judging the fabric
Most traditional trench coats are cotton gabardine, a tightly woven twill that sheds showers. It is water-resistant rather than waterproof, so in a long downpour it will eventually soak through. You cannot touch it through a screen, but you can ask for the right photos.
- The composition label: all cotton, a cotton blend or mostly polyester.
- A close-up of the weave: you are hoping for a dense, fine diagonal line. A loose or shiny weave usually means a thinner cloth.
- The coat on a hanger: good gabardine holds a clean line and soft folds rather than collapsing flat.
Linings vary. Some trench coats have a check or plain lining, some a zip-out liner for winter, and some none. If the listing mentions a removable liner, check it comes too.
The parts that go missing
A trench has more parts than most coats, and second-hand ones often arrive without some of them. Ask the seller to confirm:
- the belt, with its buckle and keeper loop;
- cuff straps and their buckles;
- every button, including the small ones on the epaulettes and the throat latch under the collar;
- D-rings on the belt, on styles that have them;
- a detachable liner or collar, if the style came with one.
Wear points to check
- Collar and cuff edges: fraying and grubby lines where they meet skin.
- Hem: scuffs and dirt from brushing against legs and pavements.
- Underarms: discolouration and thin fabric.
- Pocket openings: fraying and stretched edges.
- Seams: pulled stitching at the shoulders and the back vent.
Light-coloured trench coats show marks easily, so look at the photos in daylight. On Rewear, a seller can tag flaws such as a stain, fading or a missing button and add a close-up of each. If Rewear's photo check spotted the flaw, the tag also says which photo it is in.
What can be fixed, and what it is worth
A missing button is easy to replace, as our guide to sewing on a button shows, and a buckle can often be replaced. A missing belt is harder: it needs the same cloth in the same shade, and after years of daylight a new one may not match. Sleeves can usually be shortened, but often not lengthened by much. Yellowed underarms, set-in stains on pale cotton and worn-through cuff edges are the problems to price in, or walk away from.
So a complete trench in good cotton gabardine, graded Very good (worn, no flaws), is worth more than a Good one (minor signs of wear) with its belt missing. If a piece needs work, an offer that allows for it is fair.
After you buy
Check the care label before cleaning: many cotton trench coats are dry clean only. Between cleans, brush off dried mud, spot clean marks with a damp cloth and hang it on a broad hanger so the shoulders keep their shape.
When it arrives, try it on over a jumper before you confirm delivery in the app, because confirming releases the seller's payment. If it is not as described, open a problem report on the order within 14 days of delivery.
The short version
Fit the shoulders first and leave room for a jumper. Ask for the four measurements, and the sleeve from the collar on a raglan coat. Check the label for cotton gabardine, confirm the belt, buckles and buttons are all there, and look closely at the collar, cuffs, underarms and hem.
Advertisement
Find your next piece
Second-hand clothing from sellers across the UK, with measurements in cm where sellers add them and buyer protection at checkout.